Best Toaster Ovens 2026: Breville Air Fryer vs Cuisinart
The toaster oven quietly became the most-used appliance on the counter — it air-fries, reheats, bakes, and toasts without heating a full-size oven or your kitchen. The catch is that the cheap ones toast unevenly and the great ones eat a third of your counter, so the real question is how much oven you actually need.
We compared each toaster oven on toasting evenness and heat control, air-frying capability and capacity, interior size and counter footprint, useful presets and ease of use, build quality, and price. Specifications were checked against independent kitchen testing and long-term owner reviews, weighting real-world cooking consistency over feature counts.
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
Best Overall: The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the toaster oven that genuinely replaces a second oven. Its large interior fits a 13-inch pizza or a whole chicken, the Super Convection air-fry mode crisps as well as a standalone air fryer, and Element IQ steers heat between five quartz elements for the even browning cheap ovens never achieve — toast comes out uniform across the whole rack.
Top picks ↓Top picks
Related articles
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
The do-everything benchmark — a large interior that fits a 13-inch pizza or whole chicken, Super Convection air frying as good as a standalone, Element IQ for perfectly even heating, and thirteen presets in a premium stainless build. Big and pricey, but it truly replaces a second oven.
The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the toaster oven that genuinely replaces a second oven. Its large interior fits a 13-inch pizza or a whole chicken, the Super Convection air-fry mode crisps as well as a standalone air fryer, and Element IQ steers heat between five quartz elements for the even browning cheap ovens never achieve — toast comes out uniform across the whole rack. Thirteen presets, an interior light, and a genuinely helpful display round it out, with the best build quality here in solid brushed stainless that justifies the price over a decade. It's large, heavy, and the most expensive option, so it's overkill if you mainly toast and reheat — but for serious countertop cooking, it's the benchmark.
Pros
- ✓Element IQ delivers perfectly even toasting and baking
- ✓Super Convection air-fries as well as a standalone unit
- ✓Large interior fits a 13-inch pizza or whole chicken
- ✓Premium build and thirteen useful presets
Cons
- ✗Large, heavy, and counter-hungry
- ✗Most expensive option here
Cuisinart Toa 70 Air Fryer
The value all-rounder — capable air frying, even toasting, and a solid preset set for about half the Breville's price. A sensible size and simple controls make it the right pick for most households that want air fry plus everyday cooking.
The Cuisinart TOA-70 is the value sweet spot — a capable air-fryer toaster oven that does most of what the Breville does for roughly half the price. It has a genuinely usable air-fry function with a dedicated basket, fits a small pizza or a tray of food, offers a solid preset set, and toasts more evenly than budget units thanks to a decent convection fan. It's sensibly sized — useful for cooking without being as space-hungry as the Breville — with simple knob controls and Cuisinart's reputation for dependability. Temperature evenness, build, and air-fry crisping are a notch below the Breville, but for a reliable, affordable do-most-things oven, it's the right pick for most households.
Pros
- ✓Capable air frying for about half the Breville's price
- ✓More even toasting than budget units
- ✓Sensible size and simple controls
- ✓Dependable Cuisinart reliability
Cons
- ✗Heat evenness and build a step below Breville
- ✗Air-fry crisping slightly less intense
Ninja Foodi Sp101
The space-saving pick — a full-function air-fryer toaster oven that flips up to sit flush against the wall when idle, reclaiming counter depth. Fits a 13-inch pizza, cooks well, and is ideal for small kitchens that still want full capability.
The Ninja Foodi SP101 solves the toaster oven's biggest problem — counter space — by flipping up and back to sit flush against the wall when idle, reclaiming most of its footprint. Despite that trick it's a full-function air-fryer toaster oven with eight or nine functions, a wide interior that fits nine slices or a 13-inch pizza, and strong even heating. For small kitchens that still want full air-frying and baking but need the oven to disappear when not in use, the flip-up storage is genuinely transformative, and it cooks well enough to be a daily driver. It's the smart choice where counter real estate is precious.
Pros
- ✓Flips up flush to the wall to save counter space
- ✓Full air-fry, bake, toast, and dehydrate functions
- ✓Wide interior fits a 13-inch pizza
- ✓Strong even heating
Cons
- ✗Flip-up mechanism adds some bulk in use
- ✗Build is functional rather than premium
Breville Smart Oven Pro
The baker's pick without air fry — Breville's Element IQ even heating and a large interior with ten presets for superb toasting, baking, and roasting, at less than the air-fryer Pro. Choose it if you bake more than you air-fry.
The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the pick for bakers who don't need air frying. It brings Breville's Element IQ even-heating system and a large interior with ten presets to superb toasting, baking, and roasting, at a lower price than the air-fryer Pro. Toast and bakes come out uniform and the temperature is accurate, with the same quality build Breville is known for. It lacks the dedicated Super Convection air-fry mode of its pricier sibling, so if crisping fries and wings is central to your cooking, step up — but if you bake and toast more than you air-fry, it delivers Breville's hallmark evenness for less.
Pros
- ✓Element IQ even heating for great baking and toast
- ✓Large interior with ten useful presets
- ✓Accurate temperature and quality build
- ✓Less expensive than the air-fryer Pro
Cons
- ✗No dedicated Super Convection air-fry mode
- ✗Still a sizeable counter footprint
Panasonic Flashxpress
The compact toast-and-reheat specialist — dual infrared elements heat instantly with no preheat for fast, even toasting in a tiny footprint. Not an air fryer, but excellent at its core job for small apartments, dorms, and offices.
The Panasonic FlashXpress is the compact specialist for people who mainly want excellent toast and fast reheating in a tiny footprint. Its dual infrared elements — one quartz, one ceramic — come to temperature instantly with no preheat, so it toasts evenly and reheats fast while taking up very little space, making it ideal for a small apartment, dorm, office, or secondary oven. It isn't an air fryer and won't roast a chicken, so it's the wrong choice if you want a do-everything appliance, but for its core job of great toast and quick reheats in minimal space, it punches well above its size.
Pros
- ✓Instant infrared heat — no preheat, even toasting
- ✓Very small footprint
- ✓Fast, efficient reheating
- ✓Ideal secondary or small-space oven
Cons
- ✗Not an air fryer; limited capacity
- ✗Won't handle large items or roasts
Which one is right for you?
For replacing a second oven
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
Element IQ even heating, standalone-grade air frying, and a large interior with thirteen presets make it the best countertop oven for households that bake, roast, air-fry, and toast.
For air fry plus everyday cooking on a budget
Cuisinart Toa 70 Air Fryer
Capable air frying and even toasting for about half the Breville's price make it the right pick for most households that don't need premium build.
For small kitchens
Ninja Foodi Sp101
Full air-fry and baking capability in an oven that flips up flush to the wall when idle reclaims precious counter space without giving up function.
For bakers who skip air frying
Breville Smart Oven Pro
Breville's Element IQ even heating and a large interior deliver superb baking and toasting for less than the air-fryer Pro.
For great toast in minimal space
Panasonic Flashxpress
Instant infrared heating gives fast, even toast and quick reheats in a tiny footprint — ideal for apartments, dorms, and as a second oven.
Top pick: Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the toaster oven to buy if you want one appliance that genuinely replaces a second oven. It has a large interior that fits a 13-inch pizza or a whole chicken, a powerful convection fan with a dedicated 'Super Convection' air-fry mode that crisps as well as a standalone air fryer, and Breville's Element IQ system, which steers heat between five quartz elements to keep the temperature even — the single thing cheap toaster ovens get wrong. Toast comes out uniformly browned across the whole rack, not pale at the back and burnt at the front.
It's loaded with thirteen cooking presets (toast, bagel, bake, roast, air fry, dehydrate, pizza, cookies, reheat, and more), an interior light, and an LCD that actually helps rather than confuses. The build quality is the best here — solid brushed stainless, accurate temperature, and the kind of longevity that justifies the price over a decade. For a household that bakes, roasts, air-fries, and toasts and wants it all done well in one box, this is the benchmark.
The honest caveats: it's large and heavy, claiming a meaningful chunk of counter space, and it's the most expensive option here by a clear margin. If your kitchen is small or you mainly toast and reheat, you're paying for capacity and presets you won't use. But for serious cooking from a countertop, the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is the best there is.
Best value all-rounder: Cuisinart TOA-70
The Cuisinart TOA-70 is the value sweet spot — a capable air-fryer toaster oven that does most of what the Breville does for roughly half the price. It has a genuinely usable air-fry function with a dedicated basket, fits a small pizza or a tray of food, offers a solid set of presets (air fry, bake, broil, toast, bagel, and more), and toasts more evenly than budget units thanks to a decent convection fan. For the large majority of households that want air frying plus everyday toasting and reheating without spending Breville money, it hits the mark.
It strikes a sensible balance on size: bigger than a basic two-slice toaster oven so it's actually useful for cooking, but not as space-hungry as the full Breville. The stainless finish looks good on a counter, the controls are simple knobs and a clear display rather than an intimidating menu, and Cuisinart's reputation for dependable kitchen appliances means it tends to keep working season after season.
The trade-offs versus the Breville are real but acceptable for most: the temperature evenness and toast uniformity are good but not Element-IQ-perfect, the build is solid rather than premium, and the air-fry crisping is very good but a notch below the Breville's Super Convection. None of that matters if you want a reliable, affordable do-most-things countertop oven — which is exactly why the TOA-70 is the value recommendation.
The flip-up space-saver and the compact toast specialist: Ninja SP101 and Panasonic FlashXpress
The Ninja Foodi SP101 solves the toaster oven's biggest problem — counter space — with a clever trick: when you're done, it flips up and back to sit flush against the wall, taking up far less depth than any other unit here. Despite that, it's a full-function air-fryer toaster oven with eight or nine functions (air fry, bake, toast, bagel, broil, dehydrate, keep warm, and more), a wide interior that fits nine slices or a 13-inch pizza, and strong even heating. For small kitchens where counter real estate is precious, the flip-up storage is genuinely transformative, and it cooks well enough to be a daily driver.
The Panasonic FlashXpress is the compact specialist for people who mainly want excellent toast and fast reheating in a tiny footprint. It uses dual infrared heating elements (one quartz, one ceramic) that come to temperature instantly with no preheat, so it toasts evenly and reheats fast while taking up very little space — ideal for a small apartment, a dorm, an office, or as a secondary oven. It's not an air fryer and won't roast a chicken, but for its core job it punches well above its size.
Choose by your constraint. The Ninja SP101 is for small kitchens that still want full air-frying and baking but need the oven to disappear when idle. The Panasonic FlashXpress is for people whose needs are genuinely modest — great toast, quick reheats, minimal counter space — who don't want to pay for capacity and functions they'll never use. Both are honest about what they are.
How to choose: even heating, air fry, footprint, and presets
Prioritise even heating, because it's what separates a good toaster oven from a frustrating one. The classic budget failure is uneven toast — pale at the back, scorched at the front — caused by poor element layout and no convection. A convection fan and intelligent heat control (Breville's Element IQ is the gold standard) give uniform browning and consistent baking. If you'll toast and bake regularly, spend up for even heating; it's the difference you'll notice every single morning.
Decide whether you genuinely need air frying. A toaster oven with a strong convection fan and a basket (Breville, Cuisinart, Ninja) air-fries well and can replace a separate air fryer, saving counter space and money. But air frying adds size, cost, and complexity — if you only toast and reheat, a compact non-air-fry unit like the Panasonic FlashXpress is smaller, cheaper, and excellent at its core job. Don't pay for air-fry capacity you won't use, but if you'd otherwise buy a separate air fryer, a combo unit is the smarter purchase.
Be realistic about footprint and presets. Large do-everything ovens (Breville, and to a lesser extent the Cuisinart) claim serious counter depth — measure your space and check it fits under your upper cabinets before buying. The Ninja's flip-up design is the answer for tight kitchens. On presets, more isn't automatically better: the ones you'll actually use are toast, bake, air fry, and reheat, and a clear, simple control panel beats a wall of buttons you ignore. Match the oven's size and complexity to how you really cook, not to the longest feature list.
